According to The Athletic, Aston Villa considered Maggio a first-team option when they signed him for £10 million.

Other club staff had scouted him at Metz in Ligue 1 and at various youth teams in England. Although they admired him, they did not recommend him.
Aston Villa manager Unai Emery, however, has a different opinion.
After John Durand left the team more than a year ago, Aston Villa began looking for a younger center forward and kept an eye on Maggio for some time. The young man is physically strong and has a strong presence, and Emery was impressed by him through his match highlights.
Maggio has some rough edges, which is normal since he won't turn 17 until January. However, his physical attributes are excellent, and his shooting ability is consistent. His potential and malleability are considerable. An unnamed recruiter described his physical attributes as "amazing."
Emery then entrusted the task of further scouting to chief scout Alberto Benito.
Adam Henshaw is typically responsible for Aston Villa's young stars and loaned-out players, and Maggio should fall into this category based on age. Although the definitions vary from club to club, Aston Villa defines "young stars" as players aged 19 and under.
However, Maggio's signing was not a result of youth academy recruitment, but rather stemmed from the first team's scouting system. When he was signed, the goal was to enter the first team, not to be placed in the promising young players group first.
The transfer fee also reflects this. The £10 million Aston Villa paid to Metz on the day he turned 17 in January surprised many close to the deal, who considered it too high. This expenditure was particularly glaring given that Aston Villa was still bound by financial regulations.
Although some sources have expressed doubts about whether Maggio is worth the price, the club is well aware that a player should never be easily dismissed, especially considering Emery's record of significantly improving players' individual abilities.
Paying £10 million for a 17-year-old player who only made his senior team debut last August reflects the current market reality: traditional center forwards are scarce, while demand is high, driving up prices. Stylistically speaking, there aren't many strikers like Maggio to begin with; not only are there few with similar playing styles, but there are also few with his tall physique.
Two sources within Villa described Maggio as a "body monster." His maturity is clearly ahead of his years; he looks several years older than his peers, which is a significant advantage in itself.
A source from a Premier League club's recruitment efforts believes that Aston Villa's move involves an element of risk, but also acknowledges that if Maggio's natural attributes can continue to be developed and he is molded into a target man as expected, while maintaining a consistent goal-scoring ability, he will be extremely efficient.
Another observer close to the Villa dressing room recalled watching Maggio play when he was 16 and being impressed by his physical strength and power in duels against Lyon center-back Niakate. Niakate, now 30, recently played every minute for Senegal in the World Cup.
Despite his young age—Macho, at 16 years and 217 days old when he made his debut against Strasbourg in August, became Metz's youngest first-team player and broke a 51-year record—he showed no stage fright. On the contrary, he seemed to enjoy battling it out with his opponents up front.
Maggio arrived in Birmingham in mid-January and subsequently trained with Emery in the Aston Villa first team environment. He scored in training matches and scrimmages, impressing several teammates and coaching staff, so the manager hopes he can remain in the matchday squad for the rest of the season.
The feedback from within the club was consistently positive, recognizing not only his ability but also his overall attitude. Staff and players quickly grew fond of him, praising his attention to detail, his ability to listen, and his hard work in adapting to the new intensity and Emery's demands.
Aston Villa's first-team dressing room has always been known for its intense atmosphere, demanding, high-intensity, and even somewhat ruthless environment. However, Maggio is considered to have integrated very well; his stable personality has earned him a good impression from his teammates both on and off the field.
The only obstacle is that he cannot participate in official competitions yet, and he has to wait another year.



